Intel Proposes to Use USB Type-C Digital Audio Technologyby Anton Shilov on April 26, 2016 11:00 AM EST
- Posted in
- USB-C Digital Audio
USB Type-C has a number of chances to become the standard for data and charging connector for smartphones and tablets running either Android or Windows. However, in the long-term future, Intel wants USB-C to be even more universal (and therefore pervasive) than it is going to be, which is why at IDF Shenzhen part of one of the talks evolved around using Type-C for audio.
Audio receptacles on PCs and mobile equipment are virtually the last remaining analog interfaces of modern devices, requiring certain techniques to maintain a high audio quality and remove interference. Intel proposes to replace things like 3.5 mm mini-jack with USB Type-C which will help to add features to headsets and will simplify connections of multi-channel audio equipment to various gadgets. This is not the first time a company has proposed to replace analog audio on PCs and mobile devices, but so far, nobody has succeeded due to the ubiquity of 3.5mm. Since the industry may still not be ready to go all-digital, there seems to be a backup plan.
Various types of audio jacks to connect headphones to audio equipment have been around for decades. For example, the original 6.35 mm connector, which is still widely used by audio equipment, was invented in 1878. Meanwhile, two-conductor miniature 3.5 mm audio connector (which is the most widely used audio connector at present) has been around since 1960s. Headphone jacks have evolved; they have gained contacts to support microphones and even basic programmable capabilities to enable remote controls. However, fundamentally, the ability to listen to audio through a speaker has remained the same for over a hundred years: completely analog and barely any smart functionality. Today's smartphones are used for all sorts of different purposes and are connected to a variety of devices, which requires sophisticated interconnection technologies with high data-rates. At the same time, as phones and devices get thinner, or even to simplify some of the internal design, it gets harder to install multiple ports for various purposes. If there were to be a universal connector that does it all, including audio, Intel and some other players want USB Type-C to be that universal connector.
In fact, USB-C can be used to transfer analog audio in accordance with the specification of the connector. It all comes down as to how that audio is transmitted.
The USB-C has sideband use pins (SBU1 and SBU2) which can be used for analog audio in audio adapter accessory mode. Use of the sideband pins should not impact data transfers and other vital functionality of USB-C cables, which should make them relatively simple from the engineering point of view. In this case, the USB-C connector will just replace the 3.5 mm mini jack and may even gain some additional features, such as a thermal sensor in an earpiece could measure temperature for fitness tracking.
The concept is not completely new and we saw it years ago - back in the 2000s, Motorola used the mini-USB connector on its feature phones to enable charging, data transfers and a headset connection. The idea to use one connector for everything was not entirely bad, however, it left users without a choice of headsets. However, if the makers of devices (as well as producers of audio listening equipment) adopt USB-C, the is potential that the problem will not occur again. In the advent of digital signal transfer, this allows the headset to drive the digital-to-analog conversion, removing electronic interference from the host and potentially offering a wide array of audio results.
However, transferring analog audio using USB-C’s SBU pins is not the only thing that Intel is working on.
At present, Intel is finalizing the USB Type-C Digital Audio technology and plans to release its specification later in Q2. The company does not reveal a lot about the standard right now, but notes that it is working on updating the USB Audio Device Class 2.0 specifications to support new connector, expand the list of recent audio specifications and features, improve power management and simplify the discovery and configuration model to make the upcoming headsets as easy to use as today’s headsets.
In fact, one of the important issues with streaming audio over USB is the synchronization of data streams from the host to the receiver. The USB Audio Device Class specification solved the problem in the past and because Intel mentioned the USB Audio Device Class 2.0 in its presentation at IDF, this may mean that the new the USB-C Digital Audio spec will rely on this synchronization mechanism as well. Intel wants its USB-S Digital Audio to be backward-compatible with USB Audio (1.0 and 2.0), but naturally plans to add support for new music formats.
Usage of digital audio means that headsets should gain their own amplifiers, DACs and various other logic, which is currently located inside smartphones. Intel proposes to install special multi-function processing units (MPUs), which will perform beam forming, noise suppression, acoustic echo suppression (AES), acoustic echo cancellation (AEC), non-linear processing and other operations. The MPUs will also support HDCP technology, hence, it will not be possible to make digital copies of records using USB-C digital headset outputs. It is unlikely that audio processing will be offloaded to external headsets completely, but the latter will clearly gain their own chips. This may, however, see a spike in cost, especially at the super-low end.
A good thing about USB Type-C headsets with MPUs is that they are going to be software upgradeable and could gain functionality over their lifespan. Intel admits that such MPUs will make digital headsets more expensive compared to analog devices, but high volumes and new process technologies will help to reduce the cost of digital headsets over time. In fact, USB Audio headsets and audio chips for them are not something completely new. For example, Plantronics Audio 655 DSP headset costs $49.99, whereas CMedia’s HS-100 chip for headsets is available $1. Therefore, from the cost perspective, digital headphones should not be too much more expensive in general. Meanwhile, Intel wants USB-C digital audio headsets to offer “significant value at higher end” and have improved functionality in a bid to become popular among consumers.
The industry has successfully replaced analog cables with HDMI for video equipment in the living room and in the coming years will retire the D-Sub interconnection for computer displays. However, audio jacks have survived multiple generations as other standards have changed. In fact, Intel itself eliminated analog audio jacks in its first-generation NUCs PCs, but had to return them in subsequent generations. With USB-C Digital Audio Intel may not be alone. Google’s Android 5.0 already supports USB DAC devices and thus digital headsets. Moreover, last week LeEco released several smartphones without audio jacks, so, there are attempts to eliminate them from mobile devices already. One maker will not make any difference, but a coordinated move by market leaders, such as Samsung, LG or HTC, could have a significant impact.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
Kevin G - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkFirewire was an industry standard and more than Apple used it. For example, the original Playstation 2 had a 4 pin Firewire port.
Out of that list, the only two Apple really created for Apple's own differentiation were the 30 pin Dock connector and the Lightning connector. Recall that the dock connector came out with the original iPod which was a hair too small to use a standard USB Type B receptacle and predated micro-USB-B. In fact, the Dock connector originally didn't support USB but rather FireWire.
Lightning on the other hand, there is really no excuse for Apple creating this when the market had moved over to micro-USB.
The mag-safe connector exists in the era of proprietary power connectors. Every manufacturer has a slightly different barrel size (if they use barrels) which isn't a bad thing as they like to use different voltages. Proprietary here is the standard and Apple is no different. Thankfully USB Type-C is making everyone migrated to a real interoperable standard.
hlmcompany - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkYes. The IEEE standard for 1394a (1394 being the original) was known as FireWire 400 by Apple, i.LINK by Sony and Lynx by Texas Instruments.
trparky - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkI wish that every notebook came with a power connector similar to Apple's MagSafe connector. It would save a lot of notebooks having to go to the repair shop just because the baby/child, cat, dog, or even yourself tripped over the power wire either sending the notebook crashing to the floor or the cable getting ripped out the side of the notebook while destroying the port in the process.
Bonee - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkApple has patented magsafe in 2007, and does not license it so expect to see it only after 2027...
inighthawki - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkAnd yet the entire MS Surface lineup has magnetic power connectors that work just as well. The problem isn't Apple's patent, it's that the OEMs want to shave off a few pennies from their costs.
sprockkets - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkIncorrect. The patent is the problem and Apple has threatened others with it. The only reason why MS gets away with it is because they have a patent agreement with apple.
ingwe - Wednesday, April 27, 2016 - linkI have a Surface Pro 4 and a Macbook Pro. The Surface connector does not work as well as the Macbook.
amb9800 - Wednesday, May 11, 2016 - linkUnlike MagSafe, the Surface connector also handles a lot more than just power, hence its being larger (and inherently a bit more unwieldy).
trparky - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkIntel is just now talking about putting digital audio over the USB port. The 30-pin dock connector that Apple once had and the current Lightning port is currently the only port for modern smartphones that allows you to pipe pure digital audio into a car's stereo system. I know there's Bluetooth but again, up until recently Bluetooth audio sounded like shit after being amplified by your car's stereo system. Remember, garbage in-garbage out.
BedfordTim - Tuesday, April 26, 2016 - linkMost Dell and HP laptops use the same barrel connector.